Testimonials
What clients have said about working with McWherter Scott & Bobbitt — reviews left on Google, and letters sent to the firm directly.
Google Reviews
30 five-star reviews left on Google by the homeowners, business owners, churches and condominium associations we have represented against their insurers — in their own words.
I worked with Erin England when a home insurance company refused to pay for water loss. She helped me through the process and utilized her experience and expertise to help me get much of the money that was owed to me to help repair my kitchen. I couldn't be happier with the service, communication and professionalism along the way. I definitely recommend McWherter Scott and Bobbitt to anyone dealing with something similar.
Excellent services provided throughout a long process. Communication, knowledge of the process and the proper steps to take for premium representation are pervasive at MSB Law.
The team at McWherter Scott & Bobbitt has been absolutely instrumental in guiding us through a highly complex insurance claim. Their expert advice, hands-on assistance, and unwavering support have been truly outstanding.
Curtis, Brandon, and the entire team are exceptional professionals who genuinely care about their clients. They deserve every one of these 5 stars—and more!
I had a great experience with this firm. They are knowledgeable, communicative, and honest. MSB Law clearly demonstrated their expertise in the insurance space and were a pleasure to work with. I would definitely use them again, and I highly recommend them.
Excellent customer service and very friendly and caring people. Hard working with very fast results. Highly recommend for all of your legal needs.
This firm answered all my questions and shot me straight. This was after they knew they weren't making any money off of me. I think that shows true character and next time I need legal, I will be calling Emily Alcorn first thing. Thank you Emily and thanks to the rest of the team.
Very professional.
Promptly returned phone calls and kept me up to date with any new developments in my case.
I would definitely recommend Emily Alcorn and her firm to anyone who needs competent legal help.
This firm certainly knows how to deal with problematic consumer insurance issues and knows how to get quick and equitable resolution for homeowners who need professional legal help.
Very knowledgeable attorneyfirm. Most. Important very reasonable Ms. Emily is awsome, knowledge and very efficient
Professional. Good communication. Easy to work with. They helped us with a complex legal issue that we weren’t comfortable solving on our own.
Jonathan Bobbitt and Baker Evans were very responsive and easy to work with. They helped us navigate a contentious legal issue with a major insurer and persuaded them to accept our position and significantly increase their recognized valuation of our loss. Highly recommend these lawyers and this firm.
As a sales professional in the tech world, I’m grateful to be able to trust Jonathan Bobbitt as a resource and a counselor when I have a question and need to make sure that I’m protected. He has always been pragmatic, realistic, and helpful to me — and he has a great sense of humor! I would (and have!) gladly refer my friends or family to him if they need an employment attorney.
Brandon and his team are extremely knowledgeable in the practice of first party claims. I've worked with several attorneys in this niche discipline and Brandon's team is among the best in the nation.
Attorney Justin Gilbert is a very skilled attorney. He has been a huge supporter during a very difficult situation in my life. He is someone who you can put your full confidence in and know that he is not doing it for the money and is totally invested in your cause and will not let you down!
Justin Gilbert took care of our case quickly and professionally. We were able to resolve everything in a timely manner. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for an attorney who has your best interest in mind.
I couldn’t have been more pleased with Jonathan and all the help he provided. I had many questions and he was always happy to answer without making me feel like a burden. Nobody was willing to take on my case except for Jonathan—and the result couldn’t have been better. I strongly believe that the outcome of my case was due to his strong work ethic and extreme knowledge in these specialties. I would recommend him to anyone.
Best of the best! I've never had a bad experience dealing with these kind individuals. I'm positive that if you speak with them, you will have a great experience having your needs met as well!
I contacted this firm when my mother died to help with settling matters of her estate.... After listening to my concerns, they referred me to a firm in another state who could more appropriately assist with the estate issues. Good folk. Always wanting to do the right thing.....
I had an excellent experience working with this team! I was informed every step of the way. Every exchange was pleasant, professional, and informative. Thank you!
I had such a great experience here. The staff was super friendly and the attorneys are very professional.
This group of attorneys are AWESOME! Their professionalism & knowledge can been visibly seen through their expertise of work in each individual case!!
In all my interactions with this law firm, I have had nothing but the best care and help. The lady who answers the phone listens intently and helps me with what I need. She is AWESOME. I highly recommend this firm!
There are some places I cringe at when having to call for records, but this is not one of those places. ALL of the ladies are always soooo friendly and helpful on the phone! Great group of Attorneys! 10+ stars!
These guys are the best!! They helped me through a lot, and if it wasn't for them, I wouldn't have been able to get through my issue. Thanks again!!!
I have had the privilege working with Jonathan Bobbitt on a couple of occasions and their legal expertise is outstanding!! I believe in this firm and highly recommended them.
GMSB represented me and I was very satisfied with their services. They moved quickly and efficiently to get my case settled. I would highly recommend them if you are in need of an attorney
A very friendly knowledgeable staff that gets the job done. This law firm always goes above and beyond to help with your legal needs.
Brandon and his team produced excellent results in my commercial insurance claim. The degree of expertise, professionalism and work ethic they provided are a combination which are rarely seen and are exceptionally effective.
I met with Mr Gilbert and he was patient as i told him my story that happened to me.
He was very professional an got right down to business to help me.
Mr Gilbert got everything settled quickly an I got exactly what I asked for.
I would highly recommend him to anyone.
We worked with Justin Gilbert to successfully resolve concerns over our son’s Special Education program in Knox County. Justin understands the complex nature of Special Education Law and listens to his clients about why the issues are of such concern. He took the case to as quick a resolution as possible and truly fought for our child’s rights under IDEA and ADA. While nobody wants to take concerns to litigation, sometimes it is necessary and we are fortunate there is an attorney close by who could help us and who has helped numerous other families in East Tennessee.
My wife was forced to leave her job when she notified her employer that she was pregnant. She was told they would hold her job for 16 weeks and if she didn't return by then she would be terminated. She called Mr. Gilbert and he took her case and immediately filed the proper paper work with EEOC. In the end my wife was able to return to work to her job. Mr. Gilbert and his staff were always very professional, honest, and transparent about what to expect. I would recommend this firm to anyone.
Letters From Clients
Notes sent to the firm directly at the close of a case.
Clint,
I am writing to thank you and your firm for your excellent representation of our partners in the dispute with our insurance carrier. I want to call out Baker Evans and Clint Scott in particular for all the work they did on our behalf.
I can and will be recommending MSB Law to all of the property owners in our circle. They took a formal declination of a hail damaged roof claim to a settlement and they did this masterful work at a cost of nothing out of pocket and a very reasonable fee for the work.
Again, if you need a law firm that knows how to deal with your insurance carrier I recommend you call these guys, they will take good care of you.

The original letter.
Clint, Brandon, Lori, JL, and Team,
On behalf of the members of Central Baptist Church of Albany, GA, I would like to express how thankful we are for your unwavering commitment and perseverance. It was a true blessing to have such a dedicated and skilled legal team as our advocates. Throughout each phase of this almost decade-long journey (from pre-trial and over 35 depositions to a 4-day trial and through a complex appeals process) your team was always steps-ahead and ensured we were fully informed and prepared as well.
Please know that you made us proud, regardless of the outcome, because of your character and knowing you were doing your very best on our behalf. You guys became family through this process, and you are "simply the best". Thank you, thank you, a thousand times thank you.

The original letter.
Brandon, Matt and Lori,
On behalf of the Board of Directors, the Copper Ridge Condominium Association and me, please accept our deep appreciation for your representation and dedication.
Strange as it may seem that an Association that has been governed by homeowners for less than 10 years has been the plaintiff in more than one legal action, that is the case for our Association. So we have some comparative experience. I can say that you and your staff have far exceeded anything we had come to expect. There was never an instance of a phone call not answered and promptly, a question asked that wasn't answered quickly, courteously and fully. Since I had the opportunity to be deposed, I can also say that you and your staff provided me with information to review, prepared me for the deposition itself — again courteously and fully, and supported me throughout that long day.
I also had the opportunity to represent the Association during the Mediation process. Again you and your staff prepared me well. The process was explained in detail and my questions answered. Our strategy was developed by our team which fully included me and my concerns.
All of us are pleased with the settlement that has been reached. Again, we were constantly, completely engaged in your efforts to reach an agreement. We thank you all for the efforts you made — the highlight of which was contacting a fact witness in Australia!
I also want to share with you that because of the completeness of your preparation, your considerable legal skills and your force of character(s), I have no doubt that had we found it necessary to go to trial — we would have won the day.